THE RIGHT TO LIVE. THE RIGHT TO DIE

  • Aleksander Kitsera Danylo Halytsky Lviv National Medical University, Lviv, Ukraine
Keywords: euthanasia, suicide, end of life, physician assisted suicide, utilitarianism, terminal stage of the disease

Abstract

The author – doctor and the high education teacher is trying to answer the painful question: Is euthanasia for incurable patients, crippled, mentally handicapped, unborn children with identifi ed prenatal defects in development, possible in modern world.The question also concerns the doctors participation admissibility in the voluntary departure of a person into eternity – a suicide. How can economic calculations and mental characteristics be applied to the estimation of assessing life value for persons with limited physical and/or mental capabilities, or to unborn children? What should the attitude model of a medical worker to a person be in the terminal phase of life? The author points on the medical ethic classics views and the views of philosophers, in particular, the economists-utilitarianists. He also stops on criticism of utilitarian approach to assessing the life value for the disabled person. According to the historical facts, works of literature, press publications, leading authorities of the Christian church statements, according to his own clinical experience, the author states that the deprivation of human life is incompatible with the medical worker ethics. His task is, above all, the fi ghting against the phenomenas that accompany the terminal stage of the disease and humiliate the patient’s human dignity.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Azhar Emil Vsia zhyzn’ vperedi (All life is ahead): Translation from French Orlova.–Ozon.ru.2010:240. [In Russian]

Anisimov Romen Gary, khameleon (Romain Gary, chameleon) Translation from French EV. Havrilova). N.Novhorod:DEKOM. 2007:640. [In Russian]

Angelos Ethical guidelines in surgical patient care. Journal of the American College of Surgeons. 1999 Jan 31;188(1):55-8.

https://doi.org/10.1016/S1072-7515(98)00270-1

Berko P, Derzhko I, Pitula H, Nebeluk Filosofs’ki problemy medycyny (Philosophical problems of med- icine) Lviv,Boryslav. 2011:377–385.

Białowąs M. Z rozmyślań o śmierci (Reflections about death) Wiad.Lekarskie. [In Polish]. 1981;34(18):1581–1583.

Blicharski Postępowanie z nieuleczalnie chorym (Conduct with an incurable patient).PZWL Warszawa. 1959:211.

De Boulay S, Rankin Okno nadzieji – założycielka ruchu hospicyjnego (Cicely Saunders. The Founder the Modern hospice). Translation from English. Warszawa «Znak». 2016:400. [In Polish]

Dahlgren , Whitehead M. Politika i srategija obiespietshenija spraviedlivosti v voprosah ohrany zdorovja (A policy and strategy of providing of justice in the questions of the health care). ВОЗ Kopenhagen. [In Russian] 1992:56.

Desiat’ sposobiv, yakymy dyjavol nas duryt’ (Ten ways in which the devil is fooling us) – Credo/chasopys. credo-ua.org/2016/12/170793/. [In Ukrainian]

Engelhardt Bioethics and secular humanism: The search for a common morality. Wipf and Stock Publishers; 2011 Apr 1:224.

Frysh Maks Pomoch umeret’? (Help to die?). . 1988;(38):11. [In Russian]

Gary Romain Obitsiannia na svitanku (Promise at dawn): Translation from French Maryna K.I.S Kyiv. 2011:374.

Głuszek Wybrane problemy etyczno-moralne chirurgii (Elected ethic problems of surgery) O chirurgii polskiej końca XX wieku.-Fund. Polski Przegląd Chirurgiczny Warszawa. 2001:5-17. [In Polish]

Hailey Port lotniczy (Airport). Translation from English. «Iskry» Warszawa. 1987:269–270. [In Polish]

Hemingway E. A natural history of the dead, Hemingway- A-Natural-History-of-the-Dead. www.24 grammata.com_.pdf [In English]

Hill Susan – Ptak nocy (The Bird of Night) Translation from Czytelnik Warszawa. 1978:270. [In Polish]

Janczewski G. Wybrane zagadnienia medyczno-prawne w relacjach otolaryngolog-pacjent (Elected ethic and legally problems in relation otolaryngologist-patient). Problemy laryngologiczne w codziennej praktyce. Servier Polska Warszawa. 2000;(22):2–9. [In Polish]

Janczewski G. List do Redakcji (A letter to the Publisher) Otolaryngologia Polska 2004;58(3):1–2. [In Polish]

Jurkevich Vybrane (Elected works). Kyjiv Abriss. 2011:397. [In Ukrainian]

Nadraha. Khartija pratsivnykiv okhorony zdorovja (Charter of health workers) Translation from Polish. Papska Rada do sprav dushpastyrstva v okhoroni zdorovia. 1995: Lviv 1999:128. [In Ukrainian]

Kitsera Mystetstvo buty likarem (Art to be a doctor). Medychni Kadry veresen, zhovten. 1984;(27)1– 1. (29):2–2. (30):2–2. (31):2–2. [In Ukrainian]

Kitsera O, Kitsera O(jn.). Likar, jak faktor ryzyku (The doctor as a risk factor).Informovana zhoda conditio sine qua non (Informed consent– conditio sine qua non) Likar i pjata zapovidj (Doctor and the fifth command).–Deontolohichni aspekty rozmovy likarja z hvorym (Deontological aspects of a physician’s conversation with a patient). Formuvannia osobystosti studentiv, yak maibutnikh fahivtsiv likarskoi spravy, pratsivnykiv okhorony zdorovia ta inshyh sotsialno-orientovanykh ustanov u konteksti bioetyky (tezy dopovidej) 2003;86–88. [In Ukrainian]

Kundiev Bioetyka-velinnia chasu (Bioethics is the command of the time). Liky Ukrainy. 2002(11):55–57. [In Ukrainian]

Krokos J. Mόwić prawdę choremu (To tell a patient the truth). Polski przegląd 1992;(64): 677–680. [In Polish]

Leube K.R. von Das Ich und der Wert mises.de/Leube/Leube_Menger.pdf

Lidz , Meisel L. Informed consent and the structure of medical care. President’s Comission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine.Making Health Decisions. 1998:17–374.

Lush Gjergji Matka miłośći (Mother of love). Translated Andrzej VELAR ed. Litonova. 1994:220.

Mill J.S. The Principle of Beneficence in Applied Ethics. Stanford Encyclopedia of philosophy https:// plato.stanford.edu/entries/mill/

Morew A. Amartya Sen i ogranichennostj utalitarisma (Amartia Sen and the limit nature of utilitari- anism). Ekonomicheskije nauki. . 2010;8(69):37– 41. [In Russian]

Nadraha B. Khrystyjansjka etyka, jak osnova medychnoji deontolohii (Christian ethics as the basis of medical deontology). Narodne Zdorovja. 1993 kvitenj;9–10(37–38):1–2. [In Ukrainian]

Pyrih Likarju, bud’ inteligentom! (Doctor, be an intellectual!). Medychni Kadry. 1988 hrudenj;(35):2–2. [In Ukrainian]

Sgreccia E, Spagnolo A, Di Pietro ML. (red.) Bioetyka (Bioethics).Medycyna i pravo. 2007:425– 451,563–580. [In Ukrainian]

Sykh M. (red.) Resustsytatsia. Teoria i praktika ozhyvlenia (Theory and practice of resustitation). Translation from Polish. Pol.med.izdatelstvo. Warshava. 1976:332. [In Polish]

Tatarkiewicz Historia filozofii (History of philosophy). T1. Filozofia starożytna i średniowieczna (Ancient and medieval philosophy):81–90. T.2 Filozofia nowoożytna do roku 1830 (History of more new times till 1830):152–157, T.3 Filozofia XIX wieku i współczesna (XIX century and modern philosophy):38–41. PWN.–Warszawa, 1999. (In Polish)

The History of Utilitarianism//Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ utilitarianism-history/

Van der Veer B. Euthanasia in the Netherlands. Journ. of American Coll.Surg. 1999;(188):532–537. [In English]

https://doi.org/10.1016/S1072-7515(99)00031-9


Abstract views: 206
PDF Downloads: 138 PDF Downloads: 0
Published
2017-12-29
How to Cite
1.
Kitsera A. THE RIGHT TO LIVE. THE RIGHT TO DIE. Proc Shevchenko Sci Soc Med Sci [Internet]. 2017Dec.29 [cited 2022Jul.2];50(2):69-4. Available from: https://mspsss.org.ua/index.php/journal/article/view/108